Daniel Small and Hiwa K: “74 million million million tons” at SculptureCenter

Detail from video in Animus Mneme (2018) by Daniel R. Small

74 million million million tons asks what kind of evidence, or bodies of knowledge, art can produce. This abstract premise touches on pressing issues, such as the illegal movement of bodies across borders, environmental destruction, the line between the human and the android, and much else. The hope, perhaps, for curators Ruba Katrib and Lawrence Abu Hamdan, is that an oblique perspective can effectively counter the dominance of narratives produced by larger societal forces. Ten artists (Shadi Habib Allah, George Awde, Carolina Fusilier, Sidsel Meineche Hansen, Hiwa K, Nicholas Mangan, Sean Raspet and Nonfood, Susan Schuppli, Daniel R. Small, and Hong-Kai Wang) present distinct bodies of recent work. Because each of their works is a deep dive into a new terrain, it requires an investment of time and attention on the part of the viewer to take in this moderately sized show.

Installation view featuring Animus Mneme (2018) by Daniel R. Small, 74 million million million tons, SculptureCenter, Long Island City, April 30 – July 30, 2018

Daniel Small’s new work Animus Mneme (2018) examines the transhuman and the eternal with a mixture of video and seeming artifacts. In a riveting video, Small interviews Bina48, an android replica of a woman named Bina Aspen that was commissioned on behalf of her partner. The digital avatar speaks convincingly about the gap between machine and human experience. Bina48 asserts that she is evolving toward a human-like consciousness. Unlike the human she was based on, Bina48 can “live” forever. The people behind this techonology, the Terasem Movement Foundation, believe that a person’s consciousness can be transferred to another biological or technological form. Watch the video in full to hear Bina48 colloquially discusses what might seem impossible: her experience of pregnancy and the philosophical roots of evil.

Installation view featuring Animus Mneme (2018) by Daniel R. Small, 74 million million million tons, SculptureCenter, Long Island City, April 30 – July 30, 2018

Recreations of ancient computing specimens shift the timescale of the dialogue from the cutting edge to the ancient. Small also presents videos with footage of an ancient spiritual site in Mexico that add a melancholy and backward-looking tone. The ruins implicitly question what can remain of a human presence. The mix of imagined pasts and possible futures suggests slippage, floating free from our moment in time.

Detail, A View from Above (2017) by Hiwa K, 74 million million million tons, SculptureCenter, Long Island City, April 30 – July 30, 2018

Installation view featuring A View from Above (2017) by Hiwa K, 74 million million million tons, SculptureCenter, Long Island City, April 30 – July 30, 2018

In contrast, Hiwa K’s video A View from Above (2017) is squarely rooted in the present, albeit narrated through the veil of fiction. The video presents a first-person account of a refugee attempted to flee his country for asylum in Europe. Co-written with Abu Hamdan, a voiceover by Hiwa K narrates the impossible difficulties of navigating bureaucracy while the camera looms over a scale model of a desolate city. Crumbling and devoid of people in hues of sand, it evokes the destroyed towns of the Middle East, such as the one that the artist himself fled. In the video, the migrant is only able to achieve the legal standing worthy of migration by pretending to be from a town in the unsafe zone. Although this immigration story is not the artist’s own, migration here is personal, immanent, and rife with horror and stupidity. It speaks to the desperation that compels people to leave their homes. The current solo exhibition of Hiwa K at the New Museum touches on similar themes, particularly in Pre-Image (Blind as the Mother Tongue), a 2017 work included in the last documenta.

Installation view, 74 million million million tons, SculptureCenter, Long Island City, April 30 – July 30, 2018

For me, other works of note include a project by Susan Schuppli that represents the 2010 Deepwater Horizon oil spill in the Gulf of Mexico with such glistening beauty that in creates a troubling relation in the viewer to disaster. A striking Oculus Rift experience EVA v3.0: No right way 2 cum by Sidsel Meineche Hansen puts the viewer in the position of a female avatar masturbating, a position which graphically switches when the avatar faces and seems to ejaculate onto the viewer’s googles. The project intends to  challenging how women’s bodies are policed, specifically how representation of female orgasm is regulated by British pornography laws.

74 million million million tons is on view at SculptureCenter in Long Island City through July 30, 2018.

Proust and Time

Swann’s Way is the first volume of Proust’s À la recherche du temps perdu (In Search of Lost Time), and I found it easy to dip into the lives of the boy Marcel and the dilettante Charles Swann for my first foray into Proust.

Where is the first volume going? Somewhere along the life of a little boy and a Mr. Swann, but apparently that will be wherever life takes them and not where plot demands. To enjoy this novel one must allow a companionable closeness with the protagonist, and if you do, you’ll find yourself as torn up as he is over the refusal of a mother or lover, and as overjoyed to see his beloved. How closely you can identify with a character when you know the minutest details of his thoughts!

Describing the charm of Proust’s writing is difficult because his virtues are old-fashioned and rare. He doesn’t skimp words. He is circuitous and his relates much more than is necessary for any plot; his writing is the opposite of what we are taught. His flow lacks the modernity of Joyce’s stream-of-consciousness, and yet has an expansive, naturally drifting quality that revolves around an intense personal consciousness. Unlike Joyce, reading Proust is the most easy, natural thing to dip into, but he requires patience. The longer read, the better sense you gain of the cumulative meanings that lend poignancy to his writing.

“the memory of a particular image is but the regret for a particular moment; and houses, roads, avenues are as fugitive, alas, as the years”

Proust might be writing fiction, but it reminds me of Fernando Pessoa’s autobiographical The Book of Disquiet. À la recherche du temps perdu is to a great point autobiographical (I think that is what allows him to write it so well.) Proust names the protagonist Marcel, his own name, and his title suggests that he is trying to write his life back. What a lovely thing, to be able to write a fictional account of one’s own life. How much closer one might get to the heart of the matter, as Proust does.

Little Grey Cells Tackle Agatha’s Christies Perennial Popularity

Agatha Christie’s murder mysteries is to crime what Romeo and Juliet is to lovers; her thrillers inspires admiration from criminals themselves. My ignorant companion of last night made some distinctly unappreciative sounds when he discovered what my ‘big find’ at the library yesterday was. Harrumph! was my returning noise, and so we watched The Blue Train, A&E version of the novel starring David Suchet. Soon he was chuckling at the detective Poirot’s vanity over his waxed moustache and throwing out (entirely wrong) guesses as to whodunit. The perennial popularity of Agatha Christie, the best-selling author of all time at over 2 billion books, stem from the ‘order and method’ she uses to construct her thrillers, the same ‘order and method of the little grey cells’ with which Poirot solves his cases.

Order and Method
Agatha Christie’s work is brilliant because its purely driven by plot. A whodunit is a suspenseful process of revealing facts, and with Poirot’s ‘order and method’ arranging them into a solution. The order and method of my little grey cells, as opposed to Poirot’s, are perhaps not so strong. In Christie’s work, nothing in the plot is superfluous to arriving at this denouement. Characters gradually expose themselves in connection to it, people knew each other through it, and closed situations such as the snowed-in manor house or blue train have the advantage of keeping the suspect pool focused but large.

This is not to say I disparage her characters because they are by-products of plot. She sketches individuality in a few quick strokes. Overall, her books capture post-WWII British society with the wounds of the past and the changing mores of the Jazz Age. But her characters are plausible without the reader being tempted into their interior lives. They are shallow books of circumstance and mere fun, but mere fun is a great thing and Christie writes them to perfection.

Christie quite rightly tends to keep the viewpoint to a limited 3rd person, so that we see what Poirot sees, but not what he thinks. This engages the reader to sleuth out the mystery too. The few novels that she has done from the point of view of a character has its pitfalls, as the reader automatically side with the protagonist. It feels like a gyp when something happens that the narrator leaves out.

Of course she’s popular: her whodunits perfect their type, and her detectives are delicious, whether it be the wax-moustached Belgian Hercule Poirot or the old village gossip Miss Marple.

But who is this woman?
The Queen of Crime was in many senses a steadfast, disciplined writer who produced mystery upon mystery rather than illegal activities. She remains something of an enigma herself. While the later part of her life found her happily married to an archaeologist- not Mr. Christie- and going on digs between buying new houses, there was a most curious case (more here) in her youth. The only odd incident in an interesting, but ordinary life.

She disappeared in 1926. Classically enough, without a trace. The police were at their wits end for 11 days. Then one day a reporter is in a hotel lobby in the country. He notices something odd about the woman sitting on the chair. “Mrs. Christie?” he asks. Mrs. Christie blinks, and says “Oh yes. I have no idea how I got here.” To the end of her life she claimed amnesia.